THE ADVENTURES OF TINTIN: Blu-ray (Paramount/Columbia/Dreamworks/Amblin 2011) Paramount Home Video
In 1929
Belgian artist George Remi (who wrote under the nom de plume Herge) debuted a
beloved children's hero in 'comic album' form as a supplement to the newspaper
Le XXe Siecle. Instantly embraced by readers young and old, the series
eventually became known throughout the word as The Adventures of Tintin (pronounced Tauntaun); reproduced in 50
languages and selling more than 200 million copies worldwide: a publishing
phenomenon by most any standard. Herge, who parlayed his fictional character
into a successful Tintin magazine, and then an entire studio in 1950, produced
twenty-four comic albums, many eventually adapted for radio, theatre, TV and
finally, the movies. In many ways, Tintin is a most unlikely hero. Though only
a boy, he already has a lucrative career as a reporter, accompanied on his many
explorations by Snowy (Milou in French); his ever-faithful fox terrier. He is
intellectual and well-rounded, with a probing fascination, yet naive
understanding of the world. Critics have often misconstrued Tintin as 'bland'.
But what Herge has done is to give his reader a sort of 'everyman' blank slate,
allowing us to become Tintin and enter these misadventures through his
thought-provoking mind.
Herge, who
never quite came around to explaining how his prepubescent, red-headed
protagonist evolved at such an early age to live alone, with no parents or even
parental heritage to speak of, at least afforded Tintin some adult
companionship along the way - most notably, the brazen liquor-soaked Irish
mariner, Captain Haddock, the intellectually stimulating/but quite deaf,
Professor Calculus (Professor Tournesel in French) and a pair of bumbling
detectives, Thomson and Thompson (Dupont et Dupond); a contemporary derivative
of Lewis Carroll's Tweedles Dee and Dum. What is perhaps most remarkable about
this series, apart from its signature ligne claire drawing style, are its
engrossing and meticulous - occasionally clairvoyant - plotlines that span the
spectrum of literary genres from action/adventure and thriller/mystery to
urbane political/social commentary - always tinged with adroit humor,
intelligent insight into the human condition, and great good taste.
And now comes The Adventures of Tintin - the movie
(2011); a long awaited, very elaborate, utterly fast paced and occasionally
enchanting 'motion capture' experiment from director Steven Spielberg and
producer Peter Jackson. Both men are long time ardent fans of Herge's work. In
fact, following the release of Raiders
of the Lost Ark (1981) Herge and Speilberg began transatlantic talks of
translating Tintin to the big screen. Regrettably, their face to face meeting
never materialized. As Spielberg and his production partner Kathleen Kennedy
were wrapping up on The Temple of Doom
(1983) Herge died, leaving their pending project in limbo. Although his widow
willingly allowed Spielberg to option her late husband's stories the next year,
Spielberg was never entirely satisfied with the script treatments that kept
coming down the developmental pipeline.
Furthermore,
he feared that the more fanciful aspects of Herge's stories could not be
satisfactorily translated into live action. The project was put into turnaround
and Spielberg eventually allowed his option to lapse. Then, in 2001 Spielberg
announced he would be renewing his option to produce a Tintin film with
Dreamworks' computer animation division. Again, the project ping-ponged back
and forth as Spielberg toyed with reconsidering live action. To this end,
Spielberg contacted Peter Jackson at Weta Digital to inquire about the
feasibility of creating a computer-generated Snowy. Jackson, who adored Herge's
books as much - if not more than - Spielberg, shot test footage with himself
playing Capt. Haddock while a digital Snowy playfully hopped around his feet.
But the more both men assessed this footage the more they recognized that such
a melding of live action and computer animation simply did not serve the story
well.
At this point,
Jackson suggest photorealistic 'motion capture' technology as a possible
solution. Although impressed with the results, Tintin's creative gestation was
once again interrupted. First, screenwriter Steven Moffat became embroiled in
the 2007 writer's strike. Afterward, a conflict of commitments to the Doctor
Who series precluded his further involvement on Tintin. Edgar Wright and Joe
Cornish were assigned to do a complete rewrite. Then, Universal Studios (who
had initially agreed to co-produce) declined to pursue the project, citing
disappointing box office on Monster
House and Beowulf, as well as
Spielberg's request for his usual 30% of the domestic gross as their reasons. Eventually
a deal was ironed out between Spielberg, Jackson, Paramount and Sony Pictures
(under the Columbia banner). Paramount had already spent $30 million on
Tintin's preproduction, but refused Spielberg's gross percentage request. Sony,
however, backed the deal, ensuring that at least the first two films in
Spielberg's envisioned Tintin trilogy would come to fruition.
Like all
Hollywood interpretations of great literature, the filmic Tintin takes artistic
liberties with Herge's work. We are introduced to Tintin (vocal by Jamie Bell)
at a Belgian street market, having his portrait painted by Herge himself.
Tintin becomes fascinated by a model of the tall ship Unicorn and purchases it
from a vendor. Moments later, Tintin is accosted by a mysterious stranger,
Barnaby (Joe Starr) who warns Tintin to leave the ship amongst the other
forgotten relics on sale. Barnaby's warning only serves to galvanize Tintin's
resolve. Ditto for his confrontation with Ivan Ivanovitch Sakharine (Daniel
Craig), who offers Tintin whatever he wants for the model, then breaks into his
apartment while Tintin is out to steal it. Before this theft, the model is
damaged when Snowy has a minor confrontation with a stray cat. In the scuffle,
the ship's mast breaks apart and a tiny metal flask with a cryptic message
inside rolls beneath Tintin's dresser.
Meanwhile,
detectives Thomson (Nick Frost) and Thompson (Simon Pegg) are 'not so' hot on
the trail of local pickpocket, Aristide Silk (Toby Jones). Tintin returns to
his apartment to discover it ransacked and the Unicorn gone. But Snowy alerts
Tintin to the metal flask under his bureau. Tintin discovers the message inside
and tucks it into his wallet, later stolen by Aristide. Venturing to
Marlinspike Hall; Sakharine's foreboding country estate, Tintin and Snowy are
assaulted by Sakharine's men, Tom (Mackenzie Cook) and Allen (Daniel Mays).
They abduct Tintin and Snowy and take them aboard the Karaboudjan - a rusty
cargo ship. There, Tintin and Snowy are introduced to another prisoner, Capt.
Haddock (Andy Serkis) whose men have mutinied against him, thanks to Tom and
Allen's goading. Tintin convinces the chronically inebriated Haddock to invest
in their adventure, and together these three escape their captors aboard a
lifeboat.
The next day
Sakharine sends Tom and Allen in a seaplane in search of Tintin and Haddock.
But Tintin skillfully shoots the plane down and, with Haddock's assistance,
takes Tom and Allen hostage. Making the necessary repairs, Tintin and Haddock
fly toward the Moroccan port of Bagghar, but crash land after a storm in the
desert. They are rescued by foreign legionnaires. Haddock now regales Tintin
with the story of the Unicorn. Haddock's ancestor, Sir Francis, was its
captain, assaulted during a sea battle by Red Rackham, Sakharine's blood
relative. Sir Francis chose to sink the Unicorn's bounty of treasure in the ocean
rather than surrender his ship to Rackham. Now Sakharine is in search of that
treasure and the three models of the Unicorn - each containing part of a
cryptic message that, once reassembled, holds the coordinates to locating the
sunken ship. Sakharine already has the first part of the message. Tintin, the
second. But the third remaining piece of the puzzle belongs to a wealthy sheik,
Omar Ben Salaad (Gad Elmaleh) - though not for long.
At a lavish
reception at Salaad's palace, Sakharine sends his trained falcon to retrieve
the model. This results in an extraordinary chase through Bagghar's crowded
streets, with Tintin and Haddock eventually cornering Sakharine and his men at
the docks - thanks to the last minute intervention of Thomson and Thompson. It seems
that, having retrieved Tintin's wallet from Aristide Silk, this bungling pair
have inexplicably managed to tail Tintin and Haddock to Bagghar. Reuniting the
three Unicorn scrolls, Tintin and Haddock learn that Marlinspike Hall was built
by Sir Francis. Returning to the estate, they discover a small consignment of
the Unicorn's plunder hidden behind a wall in the cellar. Haddock, now sober
and fascinated by his own ancestry, vows to assist Tintin in salvaging the rest
of the Unicorn's lost sunken treasure.
The Adventures of Tintin is a mostly
enjoyable action/adventure yarn with elements of film noir peppered throughout.
From a purely visual standpoint the film is a wondrous, if mildly absurd,
amalgam of blisteringly surreal images. What is less successful is Spielberg's
hurling his camera about this meticulously crafted computerized realm as though
it were a pinball flipped about with nauseating results. We soar up, then down
through stormy skies over the ocean, dive deep into the sea during a flashback
sequence aboard the Unicorn, and careen with violent abandonment through the
streets of Bagghar on a motorcycle. This sort of constantly moving backdrop
will appeal mostly to today's generation, weaned on rapidly edited music video
pulp and video game nonsense. However, as an artifact of pure cinema the
results tend to overpower, rather than excite, our senses.
Perhaps
Spielberg has forgotten that 'action' is best explored through the motivations
and confrontations between a film's pro- and antagonist - not the immediate
result of some manic manipulations of the cinema space through choppy camera
work and heavy-handed editing. Mingzhi Lin and Charles Pottier's SFX are first
rate, creating three dimensional flesh and blood renderings of Herge's one
dimensional cartoon drawings. Yet, in perusing the pages of Herge's comic
albums, I was struck by how much emotional content there was in that one
dimensional (and simply drawn) world. Perhaps, this is where the books advance
over their filmic counterpart.
While the
characters in Spielberg's film all look like reasonable facsimiles of Herge's
imagination, and move realistically as they should, they somehow never entirely
come to life on the screen. Technologically proficient in all their vastly
superior detailing, they nevertheless lack that intuitive humanizing quality to
truly be believed. The Moffat, Wright, Cornish screenplay brilliantly binds
three of Herge's most memorable tales into one cohesive narrative that moves
along nimbly and with a genuine feel for its source material. John William's
score is epic, yet playfully adventurous, striking just the right chord. The Adventures of Tintin will satisfy
most who see it. But it lacks the warmth and charm of Herge's original
drawings, and the staying power of a truly classic adventure yarn. Unlike
Herge's stories that have endured the test of time, we probably won't be
celebrating this film in the next century.
Paramount Home
Video's Blu-ray has been given the A-list treatment. We get a beautifully
rendered image that extols all the crisp, refined details of this digitally
inspired fantasy world. The extraordinary and subtly nuanced palette of
textures and colors all look gorgeous and razor sharp. Truly, nothing to
complain about here. And you won't find gripes from this critic over the
bombastic DTS 5.1 audio that rocks all of the surround channels. We get a
series of in-depth featurettes that cumulatively represent one comprehensive
documentary on the making of the film. Here, you will find an extensive
catalogue of all things Tintin - the movie - put together with fascinating
insight and interviews from virtually all of the cast and crew. Bottom line: If
you're a fan of this film, then Paramount has outdone themselves on ensuring
all your needs have been met. But if you're a fan of Herge's Tintin, the final
results achieved in this film may occasionally leave you wanting for something
more.
FILM RATING (out of 5 - 5 being the best)
3
VIDEO/AUDIO
5
EXTRAS
3.5
Comments