ALASTAIR SIM: SCHOOL FOR LAUGHTER - Blu-ray (ABPC/Ealing, 1947-1960) StudioCanal/Film Movement
In the annals of British cinema, few stars burned as
bright as Alastair Sim. The Edinburgh-born youth, whose true gifts as a treasured
character actor did not emerge until well into his middle-age – a time, when
most careers are, in fact, winding down – and, whose definitive portrait of Dickens’
beloved curmudgeon, Ebenezer Scrooge in 1951’s Christmas Carol continues
to reign down each festive season as the standard bearer, irrefutably is, and
quite simply, the most easily identifiable, quick-witted bon vivant of the
post-war generation. That his aged bald pate, tinged in a fringe of wispy locks,
and droopy-eyes, always to spark with more than an ounce of petty larceny,
seemed to convey the lovable warmth usually afforded a beloved basset hound in
need of a friendly pat or deft snap across the backside with a newspaper, was
all part of Sim’s unique beguilement. The Scottish thespian was, in fact, a main
staple on London’s West End almost from his beginning to his passing in 1976 –
his foray into pictures in 1935, leading to a long and happy screen life and
immortality as an artfully situated devil-may-care ever since. Though classically
trained as a dramatic actor, Sim’s métier often lent itself to seemingly
feather-weight comedies, laced with underpinnings of a more deceptive and menacing
ploy at work.
It was hardly joy galore for Sim, who found his lack
of matinee idol ‘good looks’ often suggested to others he might best be suited
as a general laborer or civil servant. Indeed, on the counsel of his father, Sim
studied analytical chemistry at the University of Edinburgh – his schooling interrupted
by conscription during WWI. At war’s end, Sim informed his family he intended
to pursue a career on the stage – an announcement so ill-received, Sim left
home as a result of it, drifting aimlessly into jobs of no account before recognizing
his strengths as a verse-speaking orator, for which he earned public
recognition and several prominent awards. Sim, more a lover of the arts –
particularly poetry – and his fastidious attention to diction, eventually resulted
in his establishing a private school for elocution and drama, co-founded by playwright,
John Drinkwater. He also taught elocution at the college in Dalry from 1922 to
1924, and went on to become a Fulton Lecturer at the university for 5 more
years. He met his future wife, Naomi Merlith Plaskitt, when she was barely 12
and he was already 26. They would marry 6 years later.
From this rather inauspicious debut, the couple would
have one of the most enduring and heartfelt unions while Sim concentrated his ambitions
to act professionally. He marked this turning point with a lowly appearance as ‘the
messenger’ in 1930’s production of Othello, toggling between high-drama
and lowbrow musical/comedy revues to fill in the gaps and gain experience.
Referenced in a review as “a marvelous mixture of soap and vinegar” Alastair
Sim began to garner critical interest and the respect of his peers in tandem –
his alliance with playwright, James Bridie, lasting until Bridie’s passing in
1951, and elevating Sim’s craftsmanship to an enviable level. By the mid-1940’s
Sim had successfully translated his acting skills to the movie screen,
appearing in Green for Danger (1946) and The Happiest Days of Your
Life (1950). The four films culled together in Film Movement’s School
for Laughter Blu-ray are an odd duck assemblage at best. Only 2 of the
offerings, The Belles of St. Trinian’s (1954) and School for
Scoundrels (1960 – and Sim’s farewell to the movies) show off Sim’s rare qualities,
while the remaining two features, 1947’s Hue and Cry – an exceptionally
dark and delicious crime/caper aimed at the kiddie sect, and, 1951’s Laughter
in Paradise – a frankly tepid and disposable comedy of errors, offer scant
highlights as ensembles for which the focus is decidedly NOT on Sim or the characters
he plays. Worst of all, Laughter in Paradise is a woefully undernourished
remastering effort, culled from disastrously careworn second-generation elements
in desperate need of a quality restoration. More on this, later in this review.
Hue and Cry is a fairly fascinating ‘dark’ thriller, ironically
aimed at children, merely singed by Sim’s brief comedic respites as the author of
some spurious pulp fiction that appeals to London’s wayward youth. The movie is
notable for being set in the then ‘present’ and showing the devastating ravages
of post-war London, with whole portions of the city still in bombed out ruins. Following
church choir practice, one such delinquent, Joe Kirby (the exceptional gifted, Harry
Fowler) reads aloud to the rest of his disenfranchised lot, collectively known
as The Blood and Thunder Boys from ‘Trump’ – a lurid comic book, alas, missing
some vital pages to continue to the story. Curious to know the ending, Kirby
buys his own copy so he can follow the adventures of its fictional detective,
Selwyn Pike. Alas, life appears to be imitating art when Kirby stumbles upon
two rough-hewn blokes carrying 3 wooden crates into Mr. Jago’s (Paul Demel) fur
shop. Deciding to investigate further, as the story suggests dead bodies are
being concealed in the crates, and, rather uncannily, the license plate on the
truck - GZ 4216 – matches the getaway vehicle in the Trump story, Kirby is
found out by Jago, who summons Inspector Ford (Jack Lambert) to press charges.
Instead, Ford encourages Jago to let Kirby go. Ford even gets Kirby a
legitimate job to fill up his leisure, working for Covent Garden grocer,
Nightingale (Jack Warner).
As Kirby still believes something criminal is underway,
he and a small contingent of his pals, to include his best friend, Alec
(Douglas Barr) attends comic writer, Felix Wilkinson (Alastair Sim) at his flat.
Kirby informs Wilkinson he believes his stories are being manipulated as code
to conduct illegal activities. Kirby tries to tell this to police too. But no
one believes him. However, Kirby finds a friend in Norman (Ian Dawson), who
helps him crack the code, revealing a robbery to take place inside the Oxford
St. Dept. Store. Determined to thwart this crime, Kirby and his boys instead
attack the undercover police, already tipped off about the crime. Barely to
escape incarceration, Norman now tells the boys about Rhona Davis (Valerie
White) whom they bind and gag while Kirby phones Nightingale. Instead, Nightingale
arrives and frees Davis. Indeed, Kirby has no idea the criminal mastermind
behind the whole affair is Nightingale. Now, Kirby gets Wilkinson to
concoct a new Trump caper to bring all the criminals together at Ballard’s
Wharf for a sting operation. Still unaware Nightingale is the man he is working
against, Kirby tells all about their plan – then, realizes what a grave error
in judgment he has made when Nightingale’s license plate and the one depicted
in the previous story in Trump perfect match.
Back at his flat, Nightingale and Davis review the
latest Trump story, mildly amused at Kirby’s cunning to bait them until
Nightingale realizes Kirby has set a trap for him at his own warehouse. Kirby
and Nightingale arrive at the warehouse at the same moment, intercepted by the
crooks who have come for their big payoff. Nightingale is knocked unconscious
by one of the crooks for not knowing the password. Now, everyone heads for
their rendezvous at Ballard’s Wharf – the criminal class, outnumbered by the
boys who intercept and foil their smuggling operation. Nightingale is pursued
by Kirby into the ruins and eventually subdued. The next day at choir practices,
the boys arrive with various sundry bruises, cuts and blisters, incurred from
their previous day’s roughhousing. Hue and Cry is a rather fascinatingly
executed crime/caper. Indeed, the picture today is sorely underrated. But as a
movie pitched to Alastair Sim fans, it never allows Sim much opportunity to
distinguish himself among its many grand delights.
The results are even more off-key for Sim in Laughter
in Paradise – an ensemble piece to afford him one good scene, exceptionally
well-played as the put-upon author of lurid mysteries who, in reality, is the
hen-pecked fiancée of a dowdy police women to whom he has been engaged for
almost ten years. Again, the crux of our tale is not situated on Sim’s comedic genius,
but rather Jack Davies and Michael Pertwee’s rather ridiculously concocted and
mostly forced scenario about four relatives forced to jump through hoops to inherit
£50,000 each from a well-known, and newly deceased practical joker, Henry
Russell (Hugh Griffith). It seems even in death; Russell is determined to hold
his family accountable for their shortcomings. Thus, his sister, Agnes (Fay
Compton) who frowns upon manual labor and treats her maid, Ethel (Charlotte
Mitchell) with utter disdain, is herself forced to attain work as a domestic
for 28 days. Alas, she falls prey to Gordon Webb (John Laurie), a ruthlessly
brittle old stick in the mud, pretending at his own invalidism to deprive his
only daughter, Joan (Veronica Hurst) of her happiness and freedom. After Gordon
suspects Agnes of being up to no good, he hires a private investigator, Roger
Godfrey (Anthony Steel) to skulk around for clues. Instead, Roger begins to
fall in love with Joan, a romance encouraged by Agnes, whose heart continues to
soften the longer she remains in service.
Meanwhile, law-abiding, ex-army officer, Deniston
Russell (Sim) has been forced to write lurid crime novels under several nom de plumes
to remain afloat financially. Upon learning of his inheritance, Den’ makes his
rather prudish fiancée, Elizabeth (the marvelous Joyce Grenfell) a promise to
be wed in a fortnight, only to discover he must first ‘fake’ a crime that will land
him in jail – leading to yet another postponement of their marriage; one, the
long-suffering Elizabeth refuses to entertain until Den’ lies to her about
being in the ‘secret service’ and therefore, on a mission requiring his utmost and
immediate attention. Instead, Deniston
makes several valiant attempts at entering into various criminal enterprises,
guaranteed to get him arrested. Alas, he cannot bring himself to steal, rob or
otherwise besmirch his reputation; that is, until Elizabeth catches him in an
innocuous conversation with his secretary (Eleanor Summerfield), resulting in Deniston
throwing a brick, disguised as a package, through the plate-glass window of a
nearby storefront, for which he is arrested and sent to jail.
Meanwhile, Den’s younger cousin, milquetoast, Herbert
(George Cole) is ordered under the will’s provisos to hold up the bank at which
he is employed, thereby re-asserting he possesses the gutsy take-charge
attitude of a suitor, suitable for Susan Heathe (Mary Germaine), his fellow bank
clerk with whom he is in love. Alas, Herbert’s boss, Mr. Wagstaffe (Ronald
Adam) is the imposing and curmudgeonly sort who chronically foils Herbert’s
attempts to fulfill his role and get the inheritance. Instead, inadvertently, Herbert
foils a genuine stick-up at the bank, barging in and waving his toy pistol to
subdue the real burglars and win back the respect of his boss. By all accounts,
Den’s other cousin, Simon (Guy Middleton) – a slick but insolvent womanizer – has
the best chance at happiness, bade to marry the first women he comes in contact
with straightaway after the reading of the will. While Simon barefacedly dallies
with the cigarette girl (Audrey Hepburn) at his club, he pursues Lucille
Grayson (Beatrice Campbell) – a woman he picks up on the side of the road after
her car has stalled. Believing his ‘love ‘em or leave ‘em’ philosophy
will ensure he continues to enjoy his bachelor’s lifestyle, even after he is wed,
Simon instead falls madly for Lucille who, without much effort, reciprocates
his ardor. At story’s end, all the participants reunite, only to learn from
Henry’s solicitor, Endicott (Ernest Thesiger) there never actually was an inheritance.
Henry was just trying to teach his family certain life lessons they now find
quite amusing – the whole affair ending with one good chuckle shared by all.
For the briefest wrinkle in time, Alastair Sim rated
very highly within the cycle of Ealing comedies, long since revered for their
erudite black humor. Regrettably, Sim skirted appearing in two of the studio’s
best offerings – 1949’s Whisky Galore! and, even more regrettably, as the
devilish mastermind in The Lady-killers (1955) – a part, tailor-made for
him, and for which Alec Guinness decidedly borrowed from Sim’s deportment and
mannerisms to will his own delightful performance in the part. In The Belles
of St. Trinian’s, Sim is cast as Millicent Fritton, the Teutonic matron of a decidedly
dodgy school for impressionable brats, barely led by an even more spurious assortment
of marms and minxes, and, Millicent’s chronic gambler of a brother, Clarence. The school is in a bad way – a crumbling,
drafty, old eyesore that residents from the neighboring village regard with
painful disdain for the pint-sized hooligans it seems to produce with all the
vigor of a carnival sideshow devoted to petty larceny. Besides, the various ‘educators’
are barely qualified to teach. Nevertheless, the Sultan of Makyad (Eric
Pohlmann) wants his daughter, Fatima (Lorna Henderson) to attend there, as his
prized collection of racing ponies are being groomed nearby. The school’s
accountant, Miss Holland (Jane Henderson) explains that without the Sultan’s
tuition the school is done for, leaving Millicent to entertain the girl, first
by absconding with the hundred pounds ‘spending money’ her father has left in
her care, but also by re-instating Clarence’s ne’er do well daughter, Arabella
(Vivienne Martin) as a fellow student, eager to befriend Fatima to pump her for
intel on the Sultan’s most celebrated race horse, ‘Arab Boy’.
After assistant head/physics mistress, Ms. Buckland
(Mary Merrall) introduces Fatima to the school’s mentors and her peers, the naïve
girl settles into her surroundings. In short order, we meet the rest of the
faculty: arts mistress, Miss Brimmer (Renée Houston), mathematics professor,
Miss Wilson (Beryl Reid), Mlle. de St. Emilion (Balbina Gutierrez) - the French
‘teacher’, geography mistress, Miss Drownder (Hermione Baddeley), English-lit
teacher, Miss Gale (Irene Handl), and Miss Waters (Betty Ann Davies), and Miss
Dawn (Joan Sims). Meanwhile, aware of the counterfeit hobbies brewing at the
school – literally – as, indeed, the girls’ primary vocation at St.
Trinian’s is to perfect bootlegger gin to be sold under the radar, Barchester
Police Superintendent, Kemp Bird (Lloyd Lamble), meets with the Ministry of
Education’s Manton Bassett (Richard Wattis) in the hopes to put an end to the
school once and for all. Alas, Bassett will do nothing. Even the two inspectors
Bassett previously sent out to investigate have since vanished into thin air. Determined
to get to the bottom of things, Bird arranges for his gal/pal, Sgt. Ruby Gates
(the sublime Joyce Grenfell), to acquire a position as the school’s new games
mistress, under the false identity of Chloe Crawley.
Witnessing the procurement of illegal alcohol, peddled
by bootlegger, Flash Harry (George Cole), Gates is appalled, but remains silent
for the time being. Meanwhile, fellow student, Florrie (Jill Braidwood), learns
of the Sultan’s racing his prized pony the next day and prods Fatima for more
details. At dawn, Arab Boy goes through his trial run, simultaneously timed by his
trainer, Arabella and some girls from a rival school. The girls desire to know
the weight of the jockey, Albert Faning (Michael Ripper). To this end, one of
their own, Amanda (Belinda Lee) seduces Faning, calculating his weight and determining
Arab Boy will win the race. At this juncture, the girls’ reason to ‘borrow back’
Fatima’s £100 to place a sizable bet, a plot kiboshed by Millicent, who then
decides she will instead use the last of the school’s savings, £400, to win
enough money to pay off its creditors. Meanwhile,
Arabella informs Clarence of the horse’s strength, sure to wreck his already
placed bets against it. Arabella suggests they ‘nobble’ the horse. Clarence,
however, thinks better on this suggestion. The next day, Clarence discovers a
gaggle of St. Trinian’s worst ‘devils’ under a tree, enjoying a ‘French’
luncheon with Miss Drownder, and, Eric Rowbottom-Smith (Guy Middleton), the
school's gardener, and Wilfred Woodley (Arthur Howard), its new fencing master. Indeed, these are the former inspectors Bird
sent to investigate the school.
A plan to kidnap Arab Boy until after the race,
concocted by Clarence and his partner, Benny (Sidney James) is unearthed by Florrie.
Clarence also learns Crawley is Sgt. Gates. With Faning’s collusion, Arab Boy
is taken from his stable to the fourth floor at St. Trinian’s. Discovering what
has become of the horse, Millicent orders Maudie (Marigold Russell) and the
rest of her conspiring brood to return the pony. The horse, however, remains within the dorm,
leaving Millicent to put up roadblocks as the school prepares for ‘Parent’s Day’.
Unable to smuggle Arab Boy back to his paddock, the girls create a diversion with
smoke bombs that leave the attending parents flabbergasted by how inefficiently
the school is being managed. Nevertheless, the girls manage to ‘sneak’ Arab Boy
back to the racetrack where he wins the race – thereupon securing Millicent the
necessary funds to pay off her creditors and keep the school open; a plan,
chagrined when the dais collapse and Millicent is left to contemplate the theft
of the school’s prized trophies.
The role of Millicent Fritton ought to have gone to
another beloved of British cinema, Margaret Rutherford, who proved unavailable
at the time, and more to Sim’s credit, as he plays the part of the matron as a
woolly and very Rutherford-ian old beef in skirts, shawl and girdle – having a
whale of a time in the process. The final movie in this collection, School
for Scoundrels (1960) is, arguably, the best. Based on Stephen Potter's Gamesmanship
book franchise, written throughout the 1950’s, the story here follows the
author’s fictional counterpoint, also named Potter (Alastair Sim) who has established
a College of Lifemanship in Yeovil for the re-education of young men desiring
to succeed in life, whatever the odds and by whatever methods at their
disposal. Interestingly, the project was first shown interest state’s side by Cary
Grant. Although the main titles only sport credits for producer, Hal E. Chester
and ‘writer’, Patricia Moyes, School for Scoundrels was actually
co-written by Peter Ustinov and Frank Tarloff. As the original director, Robert
Hamer was in the throes of another alcoholic binge at the time the picture went
before the cameras he was promptly sacked by Chester, who completed the work
himself with an uncredited, Cyril Frankel at his side.
Once again, the focus of the story is not Potter or
his school for scoundrels, but rather, the meek and subservient, Henry Palfrey
(Ian Carmichael) whose abysmal failures in sport and love lead him to
reconsider what his life could be, if only he were more devious than the men
who have presently taken advantage of him. Unbeknownst to his peers, Palfrey enrolls in
Potter’s School of Lifemanship and is promptly given object lessons in how to
outwit the wicked and seduce and manipulate the innocent. In flashback we
discover how Palfrey, having bumped into April Smith (doe-eyed and thoroughly fresh-faced
and invigorating Janette Scott) aboard a public bus, suddenly found charming,
and simultaneously bewitched by her, has nevertheless gone for the more
slippery appeal of fair-weather cad, Raymond Delauney (Terry-Thomas, in a
deliciously sniveling/seething, slick and sinister role). Worse, in his efforts
to procure a viable means of flashy transportation to squire April, Palfrey has
been swindled by used car con-artists, Dunstan (Dennis Price) and Dudley
Dorchester (Peter Jones), who sell the not-so-swift Palfrey a known, and very
gaudy lemon – the Swiftmobile. Things
are not much better at work. For although he is the boss, Palfrey is mainly
disregarded by his staff, comprised of family, who look more affectionately
toward senior clerk, Gloatbridge (Edward Chapman) for guidance. Gloatbridge,
however, is extremely patronizing towards Palfrey.
Raymond steals the night away from Palfrey who planned
to use the romantic surroundings to woo April. Instead, Raymond monopolizes the
conversation, then hurries April into his sporty roadster. The next afternoon,
he ruthlessly defeats Palfrey in a game of tennis, while casually tossing off pithy
retorts that minimize April’s impressions of Palfrey while puffing out his own
interests, despite the fact, these too are far from being altruistic. Deflated,
though hardly defeated, Palfrey now appeals to Potter to mold his interests
into a more viable solution to all of his problems. Indeed, over the next
several weeks, Palfrey proves an amiable pupil, leaving Potter to accompany him
on his ‘revenge’ scenarios. First stop – the garage where Palfrey was sold the
atrocious ‘Swiftmobile’. Dunstan and Dudley marvel at Palfrey’s supposed
pleasure at being the car’s owner. Palfrey suggests he was under-charged for
the car which, upon closer inspection, not only performs beyond its supposed expectations,
but also is considered a priceless ‘collector’s gem’ for which Palfrey hints he
has just been offered a king’s ransom by Potter. Convinced of the car’s
desirability, Dunstan and Dudley buy back the Swiftmobile, trading it to
Palfrey for an Austin-Healey and 100 guineas. Departing in his new car, Palfrey
bids the crooks farewell, moments before they realize the Swiftmobile is just
as lousy a ride as ever.
Onto work, where Palfrey alters the ledgers to suggest
Gloatbridge has incompetently managed the accounts. Shaken by the noted
discrepancy, Gloatbridge is profusely contrite, allowing Palfrey to reestablish
his authority as ‘boss’. Finally, Palfrey invites Raymond to the country club
for a tennis re-match, plying his good nature to a short-cut to pick up April.
Instead, he directs Raymond down a tight alley, wrecking the back fin of his
sports car by inadvertently slamming it into a brick wall. Upon their arrival
to the club, Palfrey plays fast and loose with his serves and volleys, easily
winning the match and showing off to April who, as yet, he plans to deflower
then dump as recompense for her preferring Raymond over him. After the tennis
match, Palfrey shows off his new sports car, offering to drop April home in Raymond’s
stead. As Raymond spies Potter quietly observing the whole affair, he now follows
Potter, allowing Palfrey and April to return to Palfrey’s apartment. Plying the
girl with a slippery glass of gin, guaranteeing she will spill the drink on
herself, Palfrey offers April his robe while he washes out her dress, leaving
it to dry by the electric fireplace, already too, having conspired to get his
landlady to bear witness to a strange girl in his room. Alas, at this juncture,
Raymond, with Potter in tow, exposes Palfrey’s little scheme. Rather than being
insulted by it, April loves Palfrey even more, and he, having forsaken revenge
upon her, now declares his undying love to her instead. As the couple embraces,
Potter attempts to explain, by addressing the theater audience; none of this
was part of his plan. As the credits begin to roll, we see Raymond getting off
the train at Yeovil, heading for Potter’s school to inspire him.
Only 3 of the 4 movies included in Alastair Sim:
School for Laughter have been afforded the proper archival preservation and
restoration efforts. The black sheep of this lot is Laughter in Paradise.
What a shoddy effort it is too. Arguably, the original negatives no longer
survive. So, Film Movement is working backwards from a first-generation print
master that is in a perilous state of disrepair. Age-related damage is so egregiously
represented it positively destroys all hope of one’s viewing enjoyment. We are
not referring to a few light speckles and scratches. There are massive tears
throughout this presentation, heavy speckling, deep scratches and hugely
distracting gate weave and wobble. On top of this, vertical lines run along the
right side of the frame for interminable stretches of run time. Contrast is anemic,
leaving the overall image, fuzzy, soft and excessively grainy. Long-shots
appear almost out of focus. Awful too – the 2.0 soundtrack, sporting a heavily
muffled characteristic, further to distort and distract from the audibility of
the dialogue. Junk – pure and simple. This disc is a Frisbee!
There is far better news for the remaining 3 movies in
this set. For starters, each has been afforded the necessary restoration. So,
virtually all of the image issues previously discussed have been eradicated on
the remaining 3 movies which fare similarly. Therefore, comments made herein
apply to all. The B&W images are refined, with excellent gray scale, good tonality,
a slight smattering of film grain looking very indigenous to its source. The image
is also beautifully contrasted. The Belles of St. Trinian’s and School
for Scoundrels are both represented in 1.85:1 widescreen. Hue and Cry
is framed in the traditional Academy ratio – 1.33:1. On all 3, the 2.0 PCM
soundtracks has been properly restored and remastered, yielding excellent
clarity in dialogue, music and SFX.
Extras are heavily placed on ‘St. Trinian’s’
– clearly considered the crown jewel of this set, although I personally preferred
School for Scoundrels to it. On St.
Trinian’s, we get a 19-min. monologue with historian, Geoff Brown –
dull, but chocked full of details, 13-mins. with UEA’s Melanie Williams, barely
5-mins. with Alastair Sim’s daughter, Merlith McKendrick, and 12-mins. with De
Monfort prof, Steve Chibnall, plus a vintage 17-min. featurette on the ‘girls’
who inspired the cartoon series. School for Scoundrels contains only several
noteworthy extras, a 14-min. address from The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw,
nearly 11-mins. with Terry-Thomas biographer, Graham McCann, and 12-minutes
with Chris Potter – the grandson of Stephen Potter. Laughter in Paradise
has virtually NO extras – not even a trailer, while Hue and Cry contains
barely 6-minutes, again, with De Monfort’s Steve Chibnall – a very truncated
summation of the movie’s importance, followed by a rather pointless 9 min. tour
of locations used in the movie, but as they appear today, hosted by historian,
Richard Dacre, reduced to the role of a glorified tour guide. Bottom line: I would have had more respect
for this compendium if it had not whetted my appetite falsely as a treasure
trove devoted to Alastair Sim. Sim’s most prominent role here is in The
Belles of St. Trinian’s. A truer homage to Sim would have also included
1951’s Scrooge (a.k.a A Christmas Carol) and 1954’s An Inspector
Calls, both features showcasing Sim in the driver’s seat and exemplars as
to why he endures as a beloved among the classic English stars. Alas, Sim is
barely visible in at least three of these outings, a mere appendage – nee,
supporting player – who undeniably brightens each movie immensely, but does not
command the screen in ways that warrant any of the aforementioned movies to be
considered as Alastair Sim’s comedies. No, they are Ealing comedies, ably
assisted by Alastair Sim’s name, sold as cache – though often, well below the
title. Judge and buy accordingly.
FILM RATING (out of 5 – 5 being the best)
The Belles of St. Trinian’s – 4
School for Scoundrels – 5+
Laughter in Paradise – 2.5
Hue and Cry – 4
VIDEO/AUDIO
The Belles of St. Trinian’s – 4.5
School for Scoundrels – 4
Laughter in Paradise – 1.5
Hue and Cry – 3.5
EXTRAS
3.5
Comments